
A television report, a bill, an ANSES opinion: cadmium in phosphate fertilizers has become a political subject. For a fertilizer buyer or a phosphate manufacturer, the question comes down to thresholds in figures and to rock origins.
Cadmium accompanies phosphorus from the deposit to the bag. According to L’Élémentarium, phosphate rock sometimes contains 5 to 150 ppm of it, depending on the geology of the deposit. Between the rock and the fertilizer comes the attack with sulfuric acid, and therefore with sulfur; our page on sulfur trading describes that raw material. Our view fits in one line: the debate on cadmium in phosphate fertilizers would gain from separating the legal threshold, which is 60 mg/kg of P2O5, from the actual content of imported products, often far lower.
Cadmium in phosphate fertilizers: where exactly does the metal come from?
Cadmium travels with the ore, from the deposit to the granule. Marine sedimentary phosphates, which make up most of world trade, contain more of it than phosphates of igneous origin. The explanatory memorandum of the bill tabled in the French National Assembly thus cites 20 mg/kg for Russian phosphates and 60 mg/kg for Moroccan phosphates, two orders of magnitude that shape the European market. These figures explain why the negotiation of the cadmium threshold for phosphate fertilizers was accompanied by a trade negotiation between the European Union and its suppliers.
Cadmium in phosphate fertilizers: what the sulfuric attack changes
Turning the rock into phosphoric acid goes through the wet process, that is, an attack with sulfuric acid. L’Élémentarium puts this consumption at 2.4 to 2.9 tonnes of 100% sulfuric acid per tonne of P2O5 produced, for world phosphoric acid production of 44.4 million tonnes of P2O5 in 2023. Each tonne of DAP, TSP or single superphosphate therefore takes a lot of sulfur, a subject developed in our articles on single and triple superphosphate and on the relationship between sulfur, sulfuric acid and phosphate fertilizers.
Cadmium is then distributed between the acid and the phosphogypsum according to operating conditions, which leaves producers some technical room for manoeuvre. The whole cadmium question in phosphate fertilizers is therefore played out in this attack unit.
Cadmium in phosphate fertilizers: what does Regulation (EU) 2019/1009 say?
The text harmonises the placing on the market of fertilising products bearing the CE marking. The Commission Decision (EU) 2020/1178, which examines the Danish national provisions, states the rule without ambiguity: the limit value for cadmium content is 60 mg/kg of P2O5, and Regulation (EU) 2019/1009 has applied since 16 July 2022. The law firm Lexion Avocats specifies that this ceiling covers fertilizers whose total phosphorus content reaches at least 5% by mass of P2O5 equivalent, which excludes low-phosphate formulas.
National derogations: the Danish example
Several Member States applied stricter rules before 2022 and have kept them. Denmark applies, according to the same Commission decision, a limit of 48 mg of cadmium per kilogram of P2O5, equivalent to 110 mg of cadmium per kilogram of phosphorus, applicable as soon as the product contains 2.3% by mass of P2O5 equivalent. On cadmium in phosphate fertilizers, the Danish trigger threshold is therefore lower than the European one, and the limit value remains twenty per cent lower.
The review clause that fell due in July 2026
The 2019 compromise included a review date. According to Lexion Avocats, Article 49 of the Regulation requires the Commission to review the limit value by 16 July 2026 at the latest, in the light of available technologies and scientific data. The same firm puts the envisaged trajectory at 40 mg/kg of P2O5 and then 20 mg/kg in the longer term.
In French law, the rule on cadmium in phosphate fertilizers rests on standard NF U 42-001-1, which today tolerates 90 mg of cadmium per kilogram of phosphoric anhydride, according to the explanatory memorandum of the bill, which proposes going down to 40 mg in 2027 and then to 20 mg in 2030.
| Framework | Cadmium limit | Scope and date |
|---|---|---|
| Regulation (EU) 2019/1009 | 60 mg/kg of P2O5 | EU fertilising products from 5% P2O5, since 16 July 2022 |
| Danish national provisions | 48 mg/kg of P2O5 | From 2.3% P2O5 |
| French standard NF U 42-001-1 | 90 mg/kg of P2O5 | Fertilizers placed on the national market |
| ANSES recommendation | 20 mg/kg of P2O5 | Health objective, with a maximum flow of 2 g Cd/ha/year |
Phosphate fertilizer hazards: what ANSES and EFSA measure
The French health agency has prioritised the levers for action against the population’s body burden, and cadmium in phosphate fertilizers comes at the top. Its report attributes more than 80% of cadmium inputs to agricultural soils to mineral phosphate fertilizers, against 14% to atmospheric deposition, and recommends not exceeding an annual flow of 2 g of cadmium per hectare and a content of no more than 20 mg of cadmium per kilogram of P2O5.
The same document notes that 47.6% of the adult population aged 18 to 60 exceeds the critical urinary concentration of 0.5 µg of cadmium per gram of creatinine in the Esteban study. At European level, EFSA maintained in 2011 a tolerable weekly intake of 2.5 µg per kilogram of body weight.
Measurements made on French harvests give a more reassuring picture in the short term. Arvalis reports an average content of 0.033 mg/kg in soft wheat across 3,164 samples, for a regulatory limit of 0.1 mg/kg, and of 0.026 mg/kg in potatoes across 2,716 samples, with the same limit on the peeled tuber. Durum wheat, limited to 0.18 mg/kg, has seen its content halve since 2010 across 700 samples.
Cadmium-free phosphate fertilizers: where do the origins stand?
The market has moved faster than the regulations. The Moroccan daily Le Matin reported in January 2025 that phosphate fertilizers exported by Morocco to Europe showed a cadmium content below 20 mg/kg of P2O5, the level recommended by ANSES and three times less than the European ceiling. A demanding buyer therefore obtains products well below the legal limit, provided the cadmium clause is written into the contract and verified by analysis.
This change rests on the selection of deposit layers, the blending of rocks of different origins and control of the attack process. It has a cost that feeds through into delivered prices, as shown by our tracking of fertilizer prices in Morocco and the context described in the 2026 global sulfur crisis.
Organic phosphate fertilizers: a stricter threshold, marginal use
Organic farming uses phosphate rock, not attacked with acid, and is concerned by the same question. After the publication of the ANSES opinion, the Fédération nationale d’agriculture biologique points out, in an article in Pleinchamp, that the limit applicable to mineral phosphates usable in organic farming is 60 mg/kg of P2O5, against 90 mg/kg for the French conventional standard. The federation adds that actual use remains anecdotal: the PhosphoBio 2024 study examined 866 phosphorus applications on more than 170 organic plots and found only one use of phosphate rock, the rest coming from livestock manures.
What E-Station does
E-Station works upstream of this chain, on the raw material used to attack phosphate rock: solid sulfur, sold as granules, pastilles or crushed lump, in bulk or in big bags, with a certificate of analysis per batch and origins outside the Gulf.
Our sulfur trading hub presents the grades available, and producers of sulfuric acid and phosphate fertilizers in the Maghreb will find the supply terms on sulfur in Morocco, sulfur prices in Morocco and sulfur in Tunisia, on FOB, CFR, CIF or DAP terms to the port of discharge. Our work stops before the cadmium question, which is decided by the choice of rock, but it determines the cost of the acid that processes it.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cadmium limit in phosphate fertilizers in Europe?
Regulation (EU) 2019/1009 sets the limit value at 60 mg of cadmium per kilogram of P2O5, for fertilising products containing at least 5% P2O5. This limit has applied since 16 July 2022 to products bearing the CE marking.
Why do phosphate fertilizers contain cadmium?
Cadmium is naturally present in phosphate rock, at contents that L’Élémentarium puts at between 5 and 150 ppm depending on the deposit. Sedimentary phosphates contain more of it than phosphates of igneous origin.
Are there cadmium-free phosphate fertilizers?
No fertilizer made from natural rock is totally free of cadmium, but contents have fallen sharply. Le Matin reported in January 2025 that Moroccan phosphate fertilizers exported to Europe showed less than 20 mg/kg of P2O5, the level recommended by ANSES.
Are phosphate fertilizers a health hazard?
ANSES attributes more than 80% of cadmium inputs to agricultural soils to mineral phosphate fertilizers and notes that 47.6% of adults exceed the urinary threshold of 0.5 µg per gram of creatinine. French harvests nevertheless remain well below food limits according to Arvalis.
What cadmium threshold applies to organic phosphate fertilizers?
According to FNAB, mineral phosphates usable in organic farming are capped at 60 mg of cadmium per kilogram of P2O5, against 90 mg for the French conventional standard. Their use remains rare, the PhosphoBio 2024 study having found only one case in 866 phosphorus applications.
Sulfuric acid producers and phosphate fertilizer manufacturers: your cadmium compliance is decided by the rock, and your production cost is decided by sulfur. Request a quotation from E-Station to compare the origins available and secure your cargoes ahead of the review of the cadmium limit planned at European level.